pages: RentReviewAdvisoryCommittee/2019-07-01.pdf, 4
This data as json
body | date | page | text | path |
---|---|---|---|---|
RentReviewAdvisoryCommittee | 2019-07-01 | 4 | Approved Minutes July 1, 2019 She is a single parent and spends 30 percent of income on rent. She is asking for a 5 percent increase instead. She mentioned that her carpet is very dirty and the landlord offered to replace the carpet if she took the 10 percent increase. However, she would rather have a 5 percent increase without having her carpet replaced. Chair Sullivan-Cheah reminded participants that this was a public meeting, and participants are not required to justify or disclose anything personal. Member Chiu asked Ms. Woldentensai how many people are currently occupying the unit. Ms. Woldentensai responded she has two sons under the age of 18. Member Chiu asked about her current job, and Ms. Woldentensai explained it is a salaried position. Chair Sullivan-Cheah asked Ms. Woldentensai whether the landlord has made any improvements to the inside of her unit. Ms. Woldentensai responded that her refrigerator and window frames were replaced. She said regular rent increases have prompted her to consider moving out of state. Chair Sullivan-Cheah asked about the money that was refunded to her because of the invalid increase from the previous owner. Ms. Woldentensai confirmed that it was decreased immediately after a 10 percent increase, which made her reconsider staying longer. Chair Sullivan-Cheah asked about her sons and length of tenancy. Ms. Woldentensai responded they attend school in Alameda. She has been residing in this apartment for six years, and living in the west side of Alameda since 2009. Chair Sullivan-Cheah asked Ms. Woldentensai whether she was asking for a 5 percent increase because it is something she could afford or because of language in Ordinance no. 3148. He clarified that the City Council created different requirements for landlords seeking increases above 5 percent, including mandatory review by the committee. Ms. Woldentensai said she was previously unaware of the ordinance and simply accepted any increase that was given by the landlord; however, she understands now and is able to afford a 5 percent increase. Chair Sullivan-Cheah asked if there were additional repairs made when they replaced the windows and balcony. Mr. King responded no. Chair Sullivan-Cheah asked about the units renting for around $2400.00, and if they are remodeled units with new carpeting and paint. Mr. King replied that the units have new carpeting, new paint, and some cases have additional renovations. For example, if cabinetry was worn out it was replaced. Mr. King said they replaced all of the toilets in renovated and non-renovated units about 6 months ago. Ms. Woldentensai stated that nothing was replaced or upgraded in her bathroom. As the parties were unable to reach an agreement, they took their seats, and the Committee began deliberations. | RentReviewAdvisoryCommittee/2019-07-01.pdf |