pages: HistoricalAdvisoryBoard/2008-10-02.pdf, 2
This data as json
body | date | page | text | path |
---|---|---|---|---|
HistoricalAdvisoryBoard | 2008-10-02 | 2 | (7-A) Certificate of Approval - PLN08-0035 - 1150 Bay Street. The applicant requests a Certificate of Approval to alter more than thirty percent (30%) of the value of a historically designated residential building for the purpose of remodeling a previous addition and adding a front porch. (DV) (Continued from the meeting of September 4, 2008.) Mr. Doug Vu presented the staff report. Mr. Craig Coombs addressed the board. He reiterated the discussion from the Historical Advisory Board meeting of September 4, 2008 and that the design adheres to the Secretary of Interior's Guidelines. He also reminded the board that the project is going to restore the structure and its historical elements. Mr. Robert Mackenson addressed the board. He gave a brief history of his experience and stated that the design is in line with the requirements of the Secretary of the Interior's Guidelines. He pointed out several features in the neighborhood, such as the setbacks and the landscaping, and suggested the design of the front porch will not protrude excessively into the front yard setback relative to the other houses in the neighborhood. Mr. Christopher Buckley addressed the board. He felt that this item has gone on too long and recommended that the board make a decision. He thinks that the board should either approve the project without the front porch or deny the project. Mr. Jerry Wilkins addressed the board. He stated that this project should be approved because it will benefit the neighborhood and the City. He also pointed out that the proposed work follows the guidelines and requirements of the City of Alameda and the Secretary of the Interior. Ms. Linda McKenna addressed the board. She mentioned some of the other projects she has worked on and stated that this project will restore the house to its original design and will be beneficial for the neighborhood. She also stated that it follows the guidelines and requirements. Ms. Dee Keltner addressed the board. She reviewed the plans with the applicants and wondered why the owners have not attended any of these meetings. She thinks the renovation is wonderful except for the front porch. She expressed concern regarding its setback and feels that it will take away from the neighborhood if approved. She is also concerned with the precedent that will be set if the porch is approved. She asked that future foliage be limited in height, width and depth to minimize the protrusion into the setback. Mr. Josiah Lewis addressed the board and noted his support of the remodel. Ms. Patricia Emerson addressed the board. She spoke to the remodel and how it will preserve the building and increase the usability of the structure. She mentioned how difficult it has become to navigate the historic preservation process. Some people sell 2 Minutes of October 2, 2008 Regular Historical Advisory Board Meeting | HistoricalAdvisoryBoard/2008-10-02.pdf |