pages: HistoricalAdvisoryBoard/2006-07-07.pdf, 5
This data as json
body | date | page | text | path |
---|---|---|---|---|
HistoricalAdvisoryBoard | 2006-07-07 | 5 | should not be applying the National Register Criteria. In the Ordinance, the National Register Criteria is sited in the definition, Sec 13-21-2, as part of the definition as Historical Monument. It is not referenced in the definition of a Historical Building. Study List. Currently there is no specific criteria in the Ordinance stating what is or what isn't eligible for the Study List. He feels this should be addressed in a future meeting. However, he feels the building does not meet the criteria of the study list. He also stated that he feels that the design quality of the replacement structure should be of the same quality of what it is replacing. He is in favor of the proposed design, with minor changes. Staff noted his changes, and informed Mr. Buckley that he may submit his comments during the design review process. Vice-Chair Miller opened the floor to Board discussion. Boardmember Lynch stated this building does not have any historic value, but would like staff to work closely with the applicant on the design of the proposed project. M/S (Lynch, Tilos) to approve Certificate of Approval,CA04-000 to approve the demolition of an existing residence at 826 Lincoln Ave. as stated in draft Resolution. 3-0-1. Ayes: 3; Noes: 0; Absent: 1; Motion carries. 4. CA05-0010, 1815 Sherman Street, Applicant: Jules Garabaldi. The applicant is requesting a Certificate of Approval to alter more than thirty percent (30%) of the historic structure, located at the above address, for the purposes of remodeling the existing single-family dwelling. The site is located at 1815 Sherman Street, within an R-2, Two Family Residence Zoning District. Emily Purdell reviewed staff report as presented. She would like the Board to omit paragraph 2 of Section III due to a staff error. The demolition plan that was submitted shows retention of the majority of the dwelling's exterior walls; including all of the first-floor front elevations and the majority of the first-floor side and rear elevations. The proposal does not include any changes to the existing porch area. Staff used the same criteria as prior application, and concluded that although there is some local history associated with this property, it is not significant enough to consider this building a historic resource. Staff feels the proposed additions and remodel of this single family home are restricted to the rear elevations and maintains the character of the existing structure, therefore staff recommends approval of the Certifiate of Approval as stated in the draft Resolution. Vice-Chair Miller opened the floor for public comment. Jules Garibaldi, owner, informed the Board that he grew up in this house, would like to expand the upper level bedrooms and feels the best way to do this is to dismantle and reconstruct. There Minutes of July 7, 2005 Regular Historical Advisory Board Meeting 5 | HistoricalAdvisoryBoard/2006-07-07.pdf |