pages: CityCouncil/2010-04-20.pdf, 13
This data as json
body | date | page | text | path |
---|---|---|---|---|
CityCouncil | 2010-04-20 | 13 | Mayor Johnson stated people could replace aluminum windows with the same; questioned whether an exception should be granted. The Planning Services Manager stated people should not be required to go through Design Review if the outward appearance does not change; language could be crafted that would specifically deal with aluminum sliders. Councilmember Gilmore stated Design Review should be required for aluminum sliders. Mayor Johnson stated the ordinance should require Design Review for anything inconsistent with the original [structure or architectural element]. The Planning Services Manager stated language could be crafted regarding existing versus original. Vice Mayor deHaan stated vinyl has some attributes for double hung windows; inquired how the issue would be handled. The Planning Services Manager stated that he does not think the issue is about materials; what a window is made of is not important if the window looks like the original design and fits with the architectural character of the home. Mayor Johnson stated Harbor Bay home owners have not applied for permits to put in new windows or install internal muttons; people have put in less attractive windows with no panes in order to have dual pane windows; inquired whether internal muttons are still a concern. The Planning Services Manager responded in the negative; stated that he wants to bring back all guidelines for consistency; the language in the Guide to Residential Design Review that states internal muttons are never appropriate needs to be struck. Councilmember Gilmore inquired what it [language] would be changed to. The Planning Services Manager responded a blanket statement cannot be applied to the Guide to Residential Design Review. Mayor Johnson stated Council made it very clear that guideless were to be guidelines, not rules. The Planning Services Manager stated adjustments would be made to the guidelines; the Design Review Program really depends on consistent training and implementation. Mayor Johnson stated a more defined, transparent process is needed; that she is not confident that a person coming in three different times would not get three different answers. Regular Meeting Alameda City Council 13 April 20, 2010 | CityCouncil/2010-04-20.pdf |