pages: CityCouncil/2008-01-15.pdf, 8
This data as json
body | date | page | text | path |
---|---|---|---|---|
CityCouncil | 2008-01-15 | 8 | historic. This house has retained some historical characteristics and could be remodeled and returned to is original Colonial Revival style"; the same logic can apply to any place in the City the house is nondescript because of alterations; the finding does not point to historic significance for the house; he cannot see how the appeal cannot be overturned. Councilmember deHaan stated certain design requirements would be necessary inquired whether compatibility with the rest of the neighborhood would be required. The City Attorney responded there would be an opportunity later on to pass on the design review should the Applicant come forward with a design to rebuild the house; stated the matter cannot be conditioned tonight. Mayor Johnson stated the Applicant should not assume that she can rebuild to the desired size if the appeal is overturned; size and scale within the neighborhood is very important; bad mistakes should not be repeated. The Applicant questioned why she would be denied when similar structures are being built. Mayor Johnson suggested that the Applicant provide a list of said structures. The Applicant stated that she is not exceeding the height of the existing structure; the footprint is not much bigger than the existing house; there do not seem to be any direct guidelines. Mayor Johnson stated design guidelines include criteria of compatibility with the neighborhood and size and scale. Councilmember Matarrese stated a process is in place that has a set of defined code requirements for setbacks, height, and design guidelines. Mayor Johnson stated guidelines have not been appropriately applied in the past. Councilmember deHaan cautioned staff to ensure that proper guidelines are applied; stated the area is zoned for duplexes. Councilmember Gilmore stated the demolition permit cannot be tied to what or what may not be built on the lot; the HAB finding is too broad and there would be no demolition anywhere in the City if Regular Meeting Alameda City Council 8 January 15, 2008 | CityCouncil/2008-01-15.pdf |